While the transmission of knowledge is central to teaching, it is equally a form of affective work—marked by constant emotional calibration, boundary-holding, and attunement to the inner worlds of others.

Education shapes subjectivity. Growing up in poverty on a 1970s council estate in a single-parent family felt bleak. (1)  Today, we might refer to such experiences as ACEs (adverse childhood experiences), drawing on the landmark research of Felitti, Anda et al.(2), and the rise of trauma-informed awareness.  School, alongside the local youth club, became a sanctuary—a space of relative safety amidst adversity.  My own education served me well. I was fortunate to be taught by professionals who combined pedagogical competence with compassion, expanding my social opportunities and improving my life chances. In hindsight, my education was trauma-informed before anyone even knew what that meant.

It’s unsurprising that this experience shaped my career in education and mental health—just as it has for many others. It’s well recognised that those who’ve lived through adversity are often drawn to helping professions like teaching. (3) They know how it feels and often hold a deep wish to spare others the same. But this motivation carries its own challenges, especially when trauma remains unacknowledged. Without reflection, unprocessed experiences can unconsciously shape our professional behaviours and drive. That’s one reason—among many—that I strongly believe emotional support and regular supervision should be standard for educators. I held this view long before leaving education in 2022 for the health and voluntary sectors, where supervision and reflective practice are embedded forms of workforce support. I remain baffled as to why this isn’t the case in schools.

The emotional labour required in schools stems from the same pressures we all manage in our lives—those shaped by society, community, and family. But for teachers, the load is magnified: on any given day, they hold emotional space for up to 30 young people (and, by extension, their families). That’s an enormous amount of emotional holding—much of it unconscious, unacknowledged, and yet deeply impactful. Vicarious and secondary trauma, compassion fatigue and burnout are real, and they take their toll. (4)

A brief word on ‘trauma’. Language is slippery – terms carry multiple meanings depending on who’s using them. Gabor Maté draws a useful distinction between trauma with a capital ‘T’ and a lowercase ‘t’. (5) The former includes catastrophic experiences like violence, natural disaster, abuse, or bereavement. The latter encompasses experiences that activate a learnt threat response to ongoing criticism, unmet emotional needs, moments of abandonment. Even something as ‘everyday’ as weaning can be experienced as traumatic for a baby.

This is why I sometimes wonder if ‘psychologically-informed’ might be a more inclusive term than ‘trauma-informed’. When we feel scared, stressed, or threatened—regardless of whether that fear is conscious—we enter a survival state. Fight, flight, freeze, fawn, or flop. But how often do we see a chair-throwing child not as “disruptive,” but as terrified? And what about the threat this behaviour evokes in their peers, and the teacher holding the space?

Making sense of trauma in the room is immensely complex. I’m cautious not to assume that there’s a formula for getting it right. Trauma-informed responses must be relational, contextual, and flexible. There is no one-size-fits-all—perhaps one reason such approaches are inconsistently applied in education, is that policy tends toward standardisation. Psychologically-informed practice is often deceptively simple in theory, but difficult in practice, because power, fear, and relational dynamics in schools are diffuse and constantly shifting.

It’s not just teachers who bear this load. Senior leadership teams, too, face enormous pressures—from shrinking budgets and managing staff wellbeing, to navigating government policy and the ever-present fear of Ofsted inspections. And I make no apology for that word: fear. While I’ve encountered kind and constructive inspectors, the looming threat of a poor judgment—affecting not only a school’s reputation and funding, but its entire relational ecosystem—is, frankly, terrifying. We’ve seen the tragic consequences of this high-stakes accountability culture.

Then there are the pressures from families. Even the most emotionally resilient teachers and school leaders feel the weight of ongoing criticism, complaints, and the time these consume—time pulled from the core purpose of teaching and learning. Over time, these cumulative stressors erode wellbeing and diminish the capacity to do the job well.

Schools mirror society. They are microcosms, shaped by the broader neoliberal landscape: standardisation, hyper-individualism, meritocracy, credentialism, normativity and the relentless push for measurable outcomes. These pressures are amplified by social media and digital surveillance. Space does not permit a full examination of these cultural forces (nor do I claim to have all the answers), but their effects are palpable and intensified for children and staff.

Signs of distress are everywhere. Children, families, and educators are leaving state education. Permanent and fixed-term exclusions are rising at an alarming rate.(6) Elective home education (EHE) is increasing rapidly. Teachers are leaving the profession in record numbers. These are not isolated decisions—they are trauma responses to a system that is becoming too painful to remain within.

To take just one example: figures from the Department for Education show that the main reason for both fixed-term (suspension) and permanent exclusions is “persistent disruptive behaviour.” But what if that “disruption” is a form of dysregulated fear?

According to The Guardian (Feb 2024), EHE numbers rose by over 10,000 in the Autumn term of 2023, reaching 92,000 children. By Autumn 2024, the number had grown again to 111,700. Geoff Barton, then General Secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders, expressed concern that this rise reflects deeper systemic issues—such as unmet special educational needs, school anxiety, and mental health challenges. (7) These are all underfunded areas, stretched beyond capacity.

This aligns with my experience of over 22 years in teaching and leadership. I’ve witnessed the cumulative effects of neoliberalism and policy cultures that prioritise standardisation and performativity over care. People do their best to meet impossible expectations—but the toll on physical and mental health is immense; schools are at the coal face.  No wonder over 40,000 teachers leave the profession each year for reasons unrelated to retirement.

So: is it time to make trauma-informed practice a non-negotiable?

Here’s the paradox. To mandate trauma-informed practice is to undermine its very principles: safety, trust, choice, collaboration, empowerment, and cultural responsiveness.  Trauma-informed approaches are not about a flawless model—they’re about ongoing reflection, questioning old assumptions, building self-awareness, and cultivating empathy. And that applies to everyone in a school community—child, parent, carer, teacher, cleaner, leader, CEO and requires some kind of therapeutic support.

Additionally, a psychologically- and trauma-informed school culture must be systemic as well as relational. Values need to be embedded in everyday school practices, as well as pedagogy. There is no universally agreed model at this stage, but some possibilities include:

·        Teachers sharing learning objectives and plans transparently with students

·        Offering children some choice in how they approach or present their work

·        Involving all stakeholders in collaborative decision-making (e.g. around processes, policy and curriculum), ideally through co-production

·        Embedding supervision, reflective practice, and emotional support into staff structures

·        Educating children about psychological processes and the link with behaviour

There is no single answer. What I can say with certainty is that I have encouraged and implemented trauma-informed ways of working across three schools in need of improvement—alongside highly competent pedagogy (by which I mean developmentally appropriate, relevant, and child-led)—and witnessed fantastic results. Academic standards have risen, school and staff attendance have improved, staff and child retention is stronger, disruptive behaviour has decreased, and most importantly, children and staff feel safe and happy.

The next step is to rigorously evaluate and codify which trauma-informed approaches work best in education, and to scale these approaches. This is exactly what Warren Larkin Associates are doing in a groundbreaking study of the implementation of our trauma-informed and relationship-driven approach in a large Randomised Controlled Trial, which recruited 100 secondary schools in England and is being evaluated by the Anna Freud Centre, enabled by a Youth Endowment Fund grant.

If we are to sustain the wellbeing and success of our schools—our children, our educators, our communities—this conversation can no longer be optional. Which is why I am proud to be working as part of Warren’s team to support this work in schools. We must consider how we can embrace the trauma-informed ethos and create educational environments that are more psychologically sophisticated.

About  Shelley England

Shelley brings extensive cross-sector experience spanning education, health, and the VCSE sector. Her strategic work in workforce development, co-production, and organisational change has led to impactful culture shifts across mainstream and specialist settings. With over 20 years in education—as a headteacher, Deputy CEO, and director—plus roles in the NHS and third sector, she offers unique insight into multi-agency working and the power of relational approaches. Passionate about trauma-informed practice, Shelley champions connection as a catalyst for positive change in individuals and communities facing disadvantage. Currently training in clinical psychoanalytic practice (UKCP), she deepens her understanding of systemic and interpersonal dynamics. As an Associate at Warren Larkin Associates, Shelley supports trauma-informed system change, workforce development, and cross-sector collaboration.

(1) Speaking from my own experience, of course.

(2) Felitti, V. J., Anda, R. F., Nordenberg, D., Williamson, D. F., Spitz, A. M., Edwards, V., Koss, M. P., & Marks, J. S. (1998). Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults: The Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 14(4), 245–258.

(3)  Bryce, I., Pye, D., Beccaria, G., McIlveen, P., & du Preez, J. (2023). A systematic literature review of the career choice of helping professionals who have experienced cumulative harm as a result of adverse childhood experiences. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 24(1), 72–85.

(5) Maté, G., & Maté, D. (2022). The Myth of Normal: Trauma, Illness, and Healing in a Toxic Culture. Avery.

(6) Gov.uk From Department for Education – Statistics on pupils who are excluded from school.  

(7) The Guardian: Number of children home schooled in England rises by more than 10,000 by Richard Adams, Education Editor